 |
Psychiatric and Psychosocial
Aspects of Chronic Fatigue and Immune Dysfunction Syndrome (CFIDS) in Children
and Adolescents
By Alan Gurwitt, MD, Child
Psychiatrist
Presented at the Connecticut CFIDS Association Workshop
for
Educators on Pediatric CFIDS, March
1, 1995
A. Children and adolescents, as do
adults, have a variety of psychiatric and psychological reactions caused by
having CFIDS.
- There is no good evidence that psychological factors
are a major cause of CFIDS, in spite of earlier claims to the contrary.
Indeed such spurious claims were a major cause of hobbling clinical and
basic research efforts and still cast a pall of doubt. It may be that
psychological factors are among the many other stressors that play a part in
the onset of CFIDS but they are not the primary cause.
- It is important to recognize that there are psychiatric
symptoms which are primarily biologically caused manifestations of
CFIDS and other, often overlapping, symptoms which are secondary
reactions to having CFIDS. The latter are the kind of psychological
reactions commonly seen in most people, including children, who have any
chronic disabling illness, as well as reactions more specific to
CFIDS.
a. Among the major primary biologically caused
symptoms are acute and chronic anxiety episodes and panic attacks,
emotional lability, sleep problems, and depression. There are in addition
a variety of cognitive effects, such as memory deficits, attentional
difficulties, language comprehension problems etc. which will be discussed
by Dr. Robert Sedgewick. SPECT scans, MRI's, EEG's, and neuropsychological
tests have been used to pinpoint affected areas of the brain, showing
organic involvement of portions of the cerebral cortex as well the limbic
system. The limbic system, linking several brain areas is complex,
contains areas that are the sites of emotions, and has connections with
both the endocrine and immune systems such that there are probable
inter-reactive feedback mechanisms. Many of these biologically-based
problems may fluctuate in severity often in conjunction with other
physical symptoms.
b. Each of the psychological symptoms can be compounded by
secondary psychological effects. For example, a teenager who is
subject to the myriad of physical symptoms (described by David Bell), told
by her physician that its all in her head (wrong), or that there is
nothing that can be done (wrong), who struggles with a mysterious illness
which can't yet be cured and about which little is known including
prognosis, who at times is confused, unable to remember names, words,
directions usually familiar and well known, who can't do what she used to
be able to do, who wants to do what her peers are doing academically and
socially but is hampered by fatigue and unpredictable cognitive resources,
is likely to become anxious and depressed. And so would
anyone!
B. There are a variety of diagnostic categories that have been
confused with the psychological symptoms of CFIDS.
- These include:
- Major depressive disorder and dysthymia
- School avoidance or school phobia
- Somatoform disorders (somatization, hypochondriasis)
- Malingering
Each of these can be distinguished from the manifestations
of CFIDS. See Tables 1, 2, 3, & 4.
Characteristics which differentiate CFIDS from
mood disorders:
|
CFIDS |
Mood Disorders |
|
Frustrating and severe fatigue but often with continued
motivation
Frequent flu like onset
Somatic symptoms include sore throats, fevers, myalgias,
visual symptoms, etc.
Sleep disorder in Non-REM phases
Depressed mood: Grief, fear and despair are
understandable, given the patient's symptoms and
circumstances
Suicidality appears to be a response to
desperation
Self-doubt
Responsive to positive stimuli
Fluctuating multi-system complaints, some vague
Decreased concentration with specific cognitive
impairments
May benefit from low doses of antidepressants although
some need standard doses and others can't tolerate any
Cognitive difficulties, somatic symptoms, and energy level
are not responsive to psychiatric treatment even if mood
improves |
Depressive episode (DSM III-R
296.2)
Fatigue accompanied by lacks of interest or
motivation
Onset not usually associated with physical
illness
May involve somatic symptoms but rarely myalgias, sore
throat, fever, or visual symptoms
Sleep disorder in REM phases
Depressed mood: Dysphoria, anxiety, and hopelessness are
inappropriate or excessive
Suicidality may be desperate, but also may be experienced
as thoughts of death or self-harm which are persistent, recurrent or
intrusive
Self-blame
Unable to respond with pleasure to praise, rewards or good
news
Presentation may include persistence and idiosyncratic,
pervasiveness of symptoms; possible recognizable syndrome of melancholia
(anhedonia, diurnal variation, early a.m. awakening, psychomotor
retardation or agitation, and anorexia); may also have brooding or
rumination, or psychotic symptoms (delusions or hallucinations)
Globally decreased concentration may be due to
preoccupations, distractibility, slowed mentation
Treatment requires full therapeutic dose of antidepressant
medication
Entire syndrome is alleviated by
treatment
|
Characteristics which differentiate CFIDS from
anxiety disorders:
|
CFIDS |
ANXIETY DISORDERS |
|
Panic attacks accompanied by fatigue, sleep disorder, and
multi-system complaints
Panic or anxiety may be clearly related to understandable
fears about illness and its effects
Avoidance behaviors such as staying at home, may not
eliminate symptoms
Anxiety symptoms are variable and may coincide with
fluctuation or physical symptoms
Anxiety symptoms may appear sporadically or independent
from worries, or in context of illness and its effects |
Panic Disorder (DSM III-R
300.01)
Somatic symptoms limited to episodes of panic or fear of a
recurrence of panic
Panic seen as extreme and unrealistic
Agoraphobia, School Phobia (DSM III-R 300.2,
309.21)
Avoidance behaviors constrict functioning but control
symptoms
Generalized anxiety (DSM III-R 300.02)
Symptoms of anxiety (autonomic hyperactivity, motor
tension, worries) are persistent and chronic
Worries and concerns are about two or more life
circumstances or events |
Characteristics which differentiate CFIDS from
somatoform disorders:
|
CFIDS |
SOMATOFORM DISORDERS |
|
CFIDS is clinically recognizable and real
Multiple symptoms
Possibly explained by infectious or immune response
mechanisms
Recognizable multi-system profile |
Hypochondriasis (DSM III-R
300.7)
Enduring and unrealistic fear or belief of having a serous
disease; no detectable pathology or actual loss of body
function
Conversion Disorder (DSM III-R 300.11)
May be single symptom
Symptom cannot be explained by any known
pathophysiological mechanism or physical disorder
Somatization Disorder (Briquet's Syndrome) (DSM III-R
300.81)
Very different profile; symptom list of 35 particular
symptoms (of which patients must have 13); does not include fatigue, sleep
disorder or decreased
concentration. |
Characteristics which differentiate CFIDS from
other psychiatric disorders:
|
CFIDS |
Other Psychiatric Disorders |
|
Symptoms are real and genuine
Symptoms are real and genuine |
Factitious Disorder (DSM III-R
301.51)
Intentional production or feigning of physical symptoms;
presumed psychological need to assume the sick role; chronic form is
"Munchausen Syndrome"
Malingering (DSM III-R V 65.20)
Intentional production or feigning of symptoms for
external incentives or personal
gain |
C. There are significant reverberations in the family and
school of a child having CFIDS but much can be done to help children manage.
1. In the family:
- Need for acceptance and support, and becoming well-informed
- Impact on the family
- Differentiating normal adolescent issues from CFIDS
phenomena
- Pacing, pacing, pacing
2. In the school:
- The importance of diagnosis and becoming informed
- Assessing the child or adolescent's energy level and work
capacity
- Arriving at a balance of time in school/home bound
instruction
3. Coping with the Sea of
Doubt
D. Treatment: Psychiatric medication and psychological
management
1. Medication
- For aid with sleep disturbance
- For treatment of associated depression
- For treatment of anxiety
- For energy level assist
2. Supportive therapy for child and
family
3. Absolute necessity that helping professionals be
well informed
|